Carriers

With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Use the links below to see more information about a company. Many of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.

Claims:

At McCarthy Insurance Group, we recognize that at the time of a claim is when you need us the most. You deserve fast and fair claim service. Our professionals will guide you through the claim process and help you in any way we can. Unlike a lot of insurance agencies, we prefer you call us when you have a claim so that we can take a hands-on approach and give you a better understanding of what to expect.
 
If you are filing a claim during business hours we encourage you to first contact us so that we can assist you with the claim process. If it is after office hours please call the 24hr, toll-free claim phone number for your insurance carrier. This will get your claim set up and assigned to an adjuster faster than waiting for our office to re-open. Please contact us on the next business day so that we can help you with the process.

Auto-Owners Logo

Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone:

517.323.1200

Claims:

888.252.4626

BCBS of Michigan Logo

Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan

Phone:

877.469.2583

Foremost Insurance Logo

Foremost Insurance Group

Phone:

888.888.0080

Claims:

800.527.3905

Frankenmuth Insurance Logo

Frankenmuth Insurance

Phone:

989.652.6121

Claims:

800.234.4433

Grange Insurance Logo

Grange Insurance

Phone:

800.422.0550

Claims:

800.445.3030

Hagerty Insurance Logo

Hagerty Insurance

Phone:

877.922.9701

Claims:

800.922.4050

Hastings Mutual

Hastings Mutual

Phone:

800.442.8277

PHP (Indiana) Logo

PHP (Indiana)

Phone:

800-982-6257

Progressive Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance

Phone:

800.776.4737

Claims:

800.274.4499

Safeco Insurance Logo

Safeco Insurance

Phone:

800.332.3226

Claims:

800.332.3226

UnitedHealthOne Logo

UnitedHealthOne

Phone:

800.657.8205

UnitedHealthcare Logo

UnitedHealthcare

Phone:

866.633.2446

Office Hours:  Monday–Friday  |  9am-5pm

Toll Free Phone:  (800) 824-3629

Middlebury Location

201 S. Main St.

Middlebury, Indiana 46540

Phone: (574) 971-2220

Mishawaka Location

802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, Indiana 46544

Phone:  (574) 259-5622

Fax: (574) 256-7822

Sturgis Location

26078 US Hwy 12

Sturgis, Michigan 49091

Phone: (269) 651-1133

Fax: (269) 483-2647

White Pigeon Location

425 W. Chicago Rd

White Pigeon, Michigan 49099

Phone: (269) 483-9300

Fax: (269) 464-2140

©

©

McCarthy Insurance Group, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy