About Us

Our History

McCarthy Insurance Group was founded in 1959. While much has changed in the first half century, our mission of providing “Quality Protection and Unparalleled Service” remains the same.


We have been located in Mishawaka since the beginning and are committed to the Mishawaka community. Our current location demonstrates our commitment. We take great pride in renovating one of Mishawaka’s oldest buildings and making it beautiful and useful once again.


In 2008 we expanded to Michigan by opening an office in White Pigeon. We are proud to see that our commitment to outstanding service and quality insurance products is appreciated in that community. Due to the ongoing success of the White Pigeon location, we opened another office in Sturgis in 2011.


McCarthy Insurance Group has been and always will be dedicated to quality insurance products and services. We will continue to maintain the high principles and top notch customer service that has enabled us to succeed for over 50 years.


Our Mission

At McCarthy Insurance Group, our mission is to provide all of our customers, both individuals and businesses, quality protection and unparalleled service by using the best resources available in today’s insurance marketplace.


Exceeding the customer’s expectation is our top priority. This is why we are an independent insurance agency representing many different insurance companies. We are able to check with multiple insurance carriers to find the one that provides the broadest coverage at the best cost for each customer.


At McCarthy Insurance, we are committed to excellence. Our team of dedicated professionals work hard to know the current insurance markets, understand your unique needs, and guide you through the process of finding the coverage that is right for you.


You deserve an insurance agency that offers one-stop shopping, customized solutions, and a commitment to your satisfaction. Find out how much better the insurance process can be when you work with our professionals.

Office Hours:  Monday–Friday  |  9am-5pm

Toll Free Phone:  (800) 824-3629

Middlebury Location

201 S. Main St.

Middlebury, Indiana 46540

Phone: (574) 971-2220

Mishawaka Location

802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, Indiana 46544

Phone:  (574) 259-5622

Fax: (574) 256-7822

Sturgis Location

26078 US Hwy 12

Sturgis, Michigan 49091

Phone: (269) 651-1133

Fax: (269) 483-2647

White Pigeon Location

425 W. Chicago Rd

White Pigeon, Michigan 49099

Phone: (269) 483-9300

Fax: (269) 464-2140



McCarthy Insurance Group, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy