Auto Insurance

Auto insurance protects your car, truck, van, motorcycle, etc. from accident, catastrophic loss or lawsuit. We look at every aspect of your current situation and provide an individualized automotive protection plan tailored to fit your needs.

We provide insurance coverage for the following vehicles:


  • Car

  • Truck

  • Van

  • Motorcycle

  • RV


The best way to ensure that you are getting the best possible rates is to insure all of your assets with the same company. Insurance companies reserve their best rates for customers with all of their business with them.

Office Hours:  Monday–Friday  |  9am-5pm

Toll Free Phone:  (800) 824-3629

Middlebury Location

201 S. Main St.

Middlebury, Indiana 46540

Phone: (574) 971-2220

Mishawaka Location

802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, Indiana 46544

Phone:  (574) 259-5622

Fax: (574) 256-7822

Sturgis Location

26078 US Hwy 12

Sturgis, Michigan 49091

Phone: (269) 651-1133

Fax: (269) 483-2647

White Pigeon Location

425 W. Chicago Rd

White Pigeon, Michigan 49099

Phone: (269) 483-9300

Fax: (269) 464-2140



McCarthy Insurance Group, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy