Established in 1959, McCarthy Insurance Group, Inc. proudly provides comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Indiana and Michigan. With more than sixty years of service supplying the insurance needs of families and businesses, we are a trusted source for home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance and more. Whether you need to insure a car or a car dealership we have an insurance solution for you.

Commercial Insurance Solutions

At McCarthy Insurance Group, we can create customized insurance solutions to help you guarantee the complete protection of your business. From workers' compensation coverage to general liability, we have the products that will help enhance your business while protecting its vital assets.

Personal Insurance Solutions

We also offer a multitude of personal insurance options for individuals and families. Our personal coverages include; home, renters, auto, high risk auto, SR-22 filings, motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles, snowmobiles, and personal umbrella insurance.

Exceptional Expertise

McCarthy Insurance Group represents multiple insurance companies, which gives us the flexibility to offer you affordable prices and individualized options. Additionally, our exceptional staff has the skill and know-how to recommend the personal, business, life, or health insurance that may be best for you. We also provide financial planning products, which include life insurance and health insurance.

Protection for your way of life

Just tell us what type of insurance you are looking for and we'll shop the top insurance carriers to get you the best coverage at the most affordable price.


Our products:

Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Homeowners & Renters Insurance
Life & Health Insurance

Office Hours:  Monday–Friday  |  9am-5pm

Toll Free Phone:  (800) 824-3629

Middlebury Location

201 S. Main St.

Middlebury, Indiana 46540

Phone: (574) 971-2220

Mishawaka Location

802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, Indiana 46544

Phone:  (574) 259-5622

Fax: (574) 256-7822

Sturgis Location

26078 US Hwy 12

Sturgis, Michigan 49091

Phone: (269) 651-1133

Fax: (269) 483-2647

White Pigeon Location

425 W. Chicago Rd

White Pigeon, Michigan 49099

Phone: (269) 483-9300

Fax: (269) 464-2140



McCarthy Insurance Group, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy